AI has taken off. Are we ready for what comes next?


I recently watched a fascinating presentation by Nina Schick, titled AI’s Takeoff Year – Live from Utrecht. I found myself reflecting on it long after the presentation had ended. Not because everything she said was entirely new, but because she brought together several developments in AI into a rather unsettling, yet compelling, picture of where humanity might be heading.

Her central proposition was simple: AI has already taken off. We may simply not have recognised the significance of the moment we are living through.

I think there is something profoundly important about that observation.

For centuries, intelligence has been regarded as an exclusively biological phenomenon. It has been the product of evolution, the human brain, experience, curiosity and the ability to reason and imagine. We have built civilisation on this extraordinary human capability. Now, for the first time in history, we are beginning to manufacture intelligence outside the biological world.

Think about that for a moment.

We are no longer merely developing machines that calculate faster, automate repetitive tasks or retrieve information. We are creating systems that can reason, write code, solve complex problems, examine their own conclusions and increasingly act independently.

Schick draws attention to frontier models such as Anthropic’s Mythos and OpenAI’s Astra. Their emerging capabilities, particularly in cybersecurity, are remarkable. Their ability to identify vulnerabilities in computer systems and develop ways of exploiting them also raises serious questions about access and safeguards. This is no longer science fiction. It is becoming an operational reality.

From artificial intelligence to industrial intelligence

One of the most interesting ideas in Schick’s presentation is that intelligence itself is being industrialised.

Until now, intelligence has been scarce. Developing expertise required years of education, experience and human effort. Its availability was naturally limited. But what happens when intelligence can be replicated at scale, made available almost instantly and accessed at an increasingly affordable cost? We have seen something similar with electricity, computing and telecommunications. Once these became scalable utilities, they transformed the economic and social order.

Could intelligence become the next such utility?

I suspect it could. Yet there is a paradox. The infrastructure required to produce this intelligence is extraordinarily expensive. Semiconductors, data centres, computing power and energy will increasingly determine who controls this new resource. The geopolitical contest is therefore no longer simply about technological superiority. It is about who controls the infrastructure of intelligence itself.

The changing relationship between humans and machines

For most of the industrial age, machines extended human physical capabilities. Computers subsequently extended our ability to process information.

AI is different. It is beginning to extend, and in some areas replicate, capabilities that we have traditionally associated with the human mind. This raises a question I find difficult to ignore.If a machine can analyse faster, write better, develop software, undertake research and increasingly make decisions, what happens to the traditional value we attach to human knowledge and expertise?

Perhaps knowing things will matter less than knowing what to ask, how to interpret the answers and when to exercise judgement. The premium may gradually shift from information to wisdom, from knowledge to discernment, and from execution to imagination.

But intelligence and wisdom are not necessarily the same thing. A system may be extraordinarily intelligent without possessing empathy, compassion, moral responsibility or an understanding of what it means to be human. We should be careful not to confuse the ability to produce an intelligent answer with the ability to understand its human consequences.

The opportunities are enormous. So are the responsibilities.

I do not subscribe to either extreme in the AI debate. The uncritical enthusiasm that sees AI as the solution to every human problem is misplaced. Equally, resisting technological progress out of fear is unlikely to serve humanity well.

The real challenge is to ensure that our ability to govern this technology keeps pace with our ability to create it.

Who controls this new intelligence? Who benefits from it? What happens to employment, economic inequality and human dignity? How do we preserve individual agency when machines become increasingly capable of making decisions on our behalf? And perhaps most importantly, how do we ensure that human beings remain responsible for the world they are creating?

And where does India stand in this emerging world?

While Schick’s presentation looks at the global AI transformation, I found myself wondering where India fits into this unfolding story.

We have much going for us: engineering and scientific talent, a globally recognised IT industry, a vibrant startup ecosystem and a vast digital population. Our experience with digital public infrastructure has demonstrated our ability to build and scale technology platforms. Yet, much of the frontier AI ecosystem — foundational models, advanced computing infrastructure, semiconductors and the capital driving this revolution — remains concentrated elsewhere.

We risk becoming enthusiastic consumers and implementers of intelligence created elsewhere, rather than architects of it. For a country aspiring to become a leading global economy, this is a strategic question we cannot afford to overlook. Our challenge is not merely to adopt AI faster, but to invest in indigenous research, computing infrastructure, talent and foundational capabilities.

We need not replicate everything others are doing. We could carve out our own space by applying AI to healthcare, education, agriculture, manufacturing and inclusive development. But we must recognise that in an age where intelligence itself becomes an economic resource, technological dependence could eventually translate into strategic dependence.

India’s opportunity is not merely to participate in the AI revolution. It is to help shape it.

A new chapter in human civilisation?

What stayed with me most after watching Nina Schick was not the technological detail. It was the historical significance of what she was describing.

Human civilisation has passed through several defining transitions: the agricultural revolution, the industrial revolution and the information revolution. Each fundamentally altered how we lived, worked and understood our place in the world. Could the industrialisation of intelligence be an even more consequential transition?

I think it is entirely possible.

We may be the first generation to witness the emergence of another form of intelligence that is not born, does not grow biologically and does not necessarily share our limitations. Whether this ultimately becomes artificial general intelligence, or something even more transformative, remains to be seen.

But perhaps the more important question is not whether machines will eventually become as intelligent as humans, or even more intelligent. It is whether we, as human beings, will become wiser in the process. Technology has always amplified human capability. It has also amplified human folly. Nuclear energy gave us extraordinary possibilities as well as the capacity for unprecedented destruction. Artificial intelligence could present an even more profound version of that dilemma.

I find myself thinking that we may be standing at the beginning of a chapter whose consequences we cannot yet comprehend. Future generations may look back at these years and wonder how little we understood about the significance of the moment.

The question is no longer whether AI will change our world. It is whether humanity is intellectually, morally and institutionally prepared for the world that AI is about to create.

That, to me, is the real conversation we should be having.

In musing….. Shakti Ghosal

When One Man Becomes an Institution: The Nvidia Story and the Fragility of Success


There is something deeply fascinating, and perhaps a little unsettling, about what is unfolding at Nvidia.

Until recently, Jensen Huang was almost synonymous with the company he founded. He was the visionary who anticipated the extraordinary potential of artificial intelligence long before it became fashionable. His leather jacket became an iconic symbol of Silicon Valley’s new power. His company, meanwhile, became indispensable to the technological ambitions of the world.

And then, quite suddenly, the narrative changed.

Personal controversies, questions of corporate governance and concerns about leadership culminated in his resignation. Nvidia’s share price came under pressure, billions of dollars in market value evaporated, and an industry that appeared invincible suddenly found itself confronting an uncomfortable question: What happens when the person who built the empire is no longer there?

I find this episode interesting for reasons that go well beyond the immediate controversy.

The first lesson is about the extraordinary power, and inherent danger, of a single individual.

There is no denying Jensen Huang’s contribution. He saw the potential of AI when much of the semiconductor industry was looking elsewhere. He made strategic bets, built an ecosystem of hardware and software, and positioned Nvidia at the center of a technological transformation. That is what visionary leadership can accomplish. It sees around corners and creates opportunities where others see uncertainty.

But somewhere along the way, Nvidia became so closely identified with its founder that the distinction between the institution and the individual began to blur.

And therein lies the danger.

When an organisation becomes excessively dependent on one person, its greatest strength can gradually become its greatest vulnerability. Decisions, relationships and even investor confidence begin to revolve around an individual. The organisation may be enormous, but its psychological architecture remains surprisingly small.

The second lesson is about the difference between building a great company and building a great institution.

A great leader creates value. A great institution creates continuity. The real test of leadership is not how indispensable one makes oneself, but how successfully one builds an organisation that can function without one’s constant presence.

We celebrate vision, innovation, disruption and financial performance. But how often do we ask a more fundamental question: If the leader were to walk away tomorrow, would the institution remain equally capable of navigating its future?

Steve Jobs left Apple with a capable successor in Tim Cook. The transition demonstrated that even the most charismatic founder-led organisations can evolve beyond their founders.

Perhaps that is the ultimate achievement of leadership: creating something that can outlive its creator without losing its sense of purpose.

The third lesson takes us beyond corporate leadership and into the architecture of the global economy.

The Nvidia story exposes an extraordinary paradox of our interconnected world.

In our pursuit of efficiency, we have created concentrations of power that can become dangerous single points of failure.

Nvidia designs the chips. Taiwan’s TSMC manufactures them. The sophisticated equipment required for that manufacturing depends on a handful of specialised suppliers, including the Dutch company ASML. An event involving one company, one individual or one geographical location can therefore have consequences far beyond its immediate boundaries.

This is what economists and geopolitical strategists increasingly describe as a choke point.

The more indispensable a component becomes, the greater the power it commands. But that very indispensability creates exposure. We have witnessed similar vulnerabilities during the pandemic, in global energy markets and in semiconductor supply chains.

Efficiency without resilience can be a rather expensive illusion.

The fourth lesson is about investors and the curious psychology of financial markets.

Markets are good at pricing expectations, but not always equally good at distinguishing between the enduring value of an institution and the perceived value of the individual leading it. When a company’s valuation becomes closely linked to the reputation and perceived infallibility of its founder, the market is effectively pricing its dependence on that individual as well.

The subsequent reassessment can be brutal.

Yet it would be simplistic to conclude that Nvidia’s technological capabilities will disappear with Jensen Huang. Its intellectual property, engineering talent, software ecosystem and customer relationships do not vanish with a change of leadership. The institution has accumulated capabilities far greater than any one individual. Its challenge now is to demonstrate that it can convert those capabilities into sustained institutional performance.

There is a difference between losing a visionary and losing one’s vision. The former is inevitable at some point. The latter is a failure of institution-building.

And finally, the larger philosophical reflection.

We spend much of our lives building things: careers, businesses, reputations, institutions and sometimes empires. In the process, we begin to believe that our presence is central to their survival. The more successful we become, the easier it is to confuse indispensability with importance. But history repeatedly reminds us otherwise. Individuals may create extraordinary beginnings. Institutions must create enduring futures.

Perhaps the true measure of a leader is not the magnitude of the empire built during his or her lifetime, but its ability to remain relevant, resilient and purposeful after the leader has left.

Nvidia will find another CEO. The AI revolution will continue. The markets will eventually find their equilibrium. But the question this episode leaves behind is much larger than Nvidia.

Have we become so good at creating extraordinary individuals that we have forgotten how to build extraordinary institutions? That, to me, is the real story beyond the memes.

In musing….. Shakti Ghosal

The World We Are Leaving Behind for the Young


Have we become so obsessed with creating wealth that we have forgotten to create possibilities?

I have often wondered whether the world we are building today is quite the world we once imagined for the generations that would follow us.

A recent article in The Hindu, titled How Neoliberalism Turned the World Against Its Young *, set me thinking. Over the past four decades, the world has witnessed extraordinary economic transformation. Markets have opened up, businesses have flourished, technology has disrupted old ways of working and unprecedented wealth has been created. India’s own journey since economic liberalisation in 1991 is a remarkable example of what opening up an economy can achieve.

Yet, there is an uncomfortable contradiction. We have a generation that is better educated, more connected and technologically more capable than any before it. And yet, many young people seem increasingly uncertain about their future. A decent job, an affordable home, financial independence and the ability to raise a family without perpetual anxiety are becoming difficult aspirations for many.

Why?

Perhaps we have become too preoccupied with measuring economic success through GDP growth, stock market valuations, corporate profits and wealth creation. These are important indicators, but they tell us only part of the story.

An economy must do more than generate wealth. It must create opportunities for people to participate in that wealth creation.

I find the growing disconnect between education and employment particularly troubling. (Recently, I have delved into this in some detail through an Employment Education equation study. I am providing the link to that study in the reference below for all who may be interested). We keep telling young people to acquire more skills, become more competitive and reinvent themselves. All good advice. But are we creating enough productive jobs for those skills to find expression?

Not everyone can become an entrepreneur, a technology professional or a startup founder. An economy also needs millions of people working productively in manufacturing, healthcare, education, logistics, agriculture and modern services.

Perhaps the problem is not simply that our young are inadequately prepared for the future. Perhaps the future itself is not creating enough opportunities for them.

This is where I believe the debate around neoliberalism becomes relevant.
Markets are powerful engines of wealth creation. But they are not designed to solve every social problem. What is profitable is not always what is socially desirable. And what appears economically efficient in the short term may carry a considerable social cost over time.

I am certainly not arguing for a return to excessive State control or bureaucratic inefficiency. We have seen enough of that. But neither should we assume that markets, left to themselves, will automatically produce an equitable society.

Education, healthcare, affordable housing, public infrastructure and social security are not merely welfare expenditures. They are investments in human capability and in the future of a nation. For India, this question is particularly important. We frequently celebrate our demographic dividend. But a young population becomes a dividend only when it is educated, skilled and productively employed. Otherwise, an enormous opportunity can gradually turn into an equally enormous frustration.

Artificial Intelligence will make this challenge even more complex. It will create opportunities, eliminate certain jobs and fundamentally alter the nature of work. The real challenge will be ensuring that technological progress expands human possibilities rather than concentrating economic rewards in fewer hands.

I sometimes wonder whether, somewhere along the way, we have confused economic progress with human progress.

We celebrate how much wealth an economy generates. Perhaps we should also ask how many lives it enables to become better.

Every generation inherits the world shaped by the choices of those who came before it. We may not be able to guarantee the young a comfortable life. But surely we owe them a fair opportunity, a sense of security and a reason to believe that effort and aspiration still matter.

A society that creates billionaires but cannot create enough dignified opportunities for its young may be celebrating prosperity while quietly accumulating discontent. The young are not necessarily asking for a perfect world. They are asking for a fair chance in the one we have created.

Perhaps that is not too much to ask. And perhaps the real test of economic progress is not how wealthy we have made the present generation, but how hopeful we have allowed the next generation to become.

In musing ….    Shakti Ghosal

References:

(1) https://www.thehindu.com/business/Economy/how-neoliberalism-turned-the-world-against-its-young/article71635741.ece

(2) The Education Employment equation : https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/india-educationemployment-equation-kolkata-laboratory-shakti-ghosal-c7ihf/

WHAT IF… the real meaning of a festival is what remains after it ends?


The pandals are coming down. The lights are fading. The city is slowly returning to its familiar rhythm.

Durga Pujo has left us with photographs, tired feet, beautiful memories and perhaps a little sadness.

But I wonder whether we sometimes mistake the celebration for its meaning.

What remains when the dhaaks fall silent?

Perhaps the kindness we showed a stranger in a crowded queue.

The laughter we shared with people we rarely meet.

The moment we paused to admire something beautiful, without asking what it cost or how long it took to create.

And perhaps, most importantly, the reminder that life is richer when we make room for wonder, togetherness and joy.

I have always believed that the end of an experience is also the beginning of a question.

So I find myself asking:

What if the true measure of Durga Pujo is not how magnificently we celebrated, but how much humanity we carry into the ordinary days that follow?

Just wondering.

— Rudra Bose, the Last writer of Kolkata

#WhatIf #RudraBose #ShaktiGhosal #Kolkata #DurgaPujo #TheLastWriterOfKolkata #Reflections

Generation Gap…..


or Just a Case of Mutual Misunderstanding?

I am now in my much-retired mode, which apparently qualifies me to dispense wisdom, whether solicited or otherwise. But I have run into a small identity crisis. What is my generation code? And what about my daughters, now in their thirties? Gen Y? Millennials? Or have they been upgraded to a version I haven’t yet downloaded?

I grew up in a world where money was scarce, telephones had wires, and a parent’s “Its dark now, come home and study” was the end of the conversation. Today, a simple “No” may trigger a discussion on boundaries, emotional safety and childhood trauma. In our time, we called it getting on with life. Perhaps we were resilient. Perhaps we simply lacked the vocabulary. Or the Wi-Fi.

We wanted our children to have everything we never had. Better schools, more choices, fewer disappointments. Somewhere along the way, we may have forgotten that learning to live without something is also part of growing up. We gave them wings and then looked rather alarmed when they decided to fly in a direction we hadn’t approved.

We encouraged them to think independently, question authority and challenge convention. They listened. Now they question our authority, challenge our conventions and occasionally treat our advice as unsolicited content to be skipped.

The nerve of it!

We believed adulthood meant a stable job, a house, a marriage and money in the bank. Our children seem to regard these as optional features in life’s subscription package. They are prone to change jobs, and embark on hundred mile car rides on weekends in pursuit of ‘fulfilment’. We call it restlessness. They call it knowing their worth. I suppose both descriptions depend on which side of the dinner table you occupy.

Technology has widened the gulf. They inhabit a universe of reels, stories and disappearing messages. I still believe a good conversation should last longer than a reel. But then, I remember our own youthful escapes into books, radio and daydreams. Perhaps every generation has its preferred method of avoiding reality.

And here is the uncomfortable bit. We cannot spend years telling our children to be fearless, independent and original, and then complain when they refuse to become smaller versions of ourselves.

We may also have mistaken our own survival strategies for universal truths. What worked for us was shaped by our times. What works for them must contend with theirs. Experience deserves respect, certainly. But it does not come with a lifetime monopoly on wisdom.

So, in my much-retired mode, I propose a truce. I shall continue offering advice, preferably before anyone asks for it. My daughters shall continue listening, preferably without checking their phones. Neither expectation is likely to be fully met.

Perhaps the generation gap is simply the distance between the world we grew up in and the world our children are trying to make. We see their choices through the lens of our past; they see our advice through the prism of a future we cannot entirely imagine.

And perhaps that is how it should be.

After all, every generation thinks the next one is getting it wrong. The next one, meanwhile, is busy wondering how the previous one ever managed to get anything right!

The trick, I suspect, is not to close the generation gap. It is to keep the conversation going across it. Preferably without turning it into a family WhatsApp debate.

In musing……………. Shakti Ghosal

What If… The Tragedy Was Not Sudden?


Rudra Bose’s diary | Kolkata 23rd October 2026

The newspapers this morning carry photographs I find difficult to look at for long.

Chorbagan. Saptami. A Durga Pujo pandal that had welcomed thousands, now a scene of devastation. Nineteen lives lost, families shattered, and a city struggling to understand how a celebration could turn into such a catastrophe.

The initial findings reported in the newspapers make for uncomfortable reading. A narrow exit passage. A locked emergency door. Temporary stalls obstructing movement. Inadequate lighting. Questions about crowd density, police presence and the arrangements for moving people to safety. Heavy rain had pushed people towards the pandal. An announcement about a possible collapse reportedly triggered panic.

The Chief Minister announced compensation of ₹25 lakh for each bereaved family. Arrests followed. A Special Investigation Team was appointed. These are immediate responses. They matter. But I find myself wondering whether we are once again addressing the aftermath of a disaster more urgently than the conditions that made it possible.

“What if the tragedy was not simply the consequence of a panicked crowd, but the culmination of many small failures that nobody stopped in time?”

I have watched Kolkata celebrate Durga Pujo for decades. Our pandals are expressions of imagination, community pride and collective enterprise. They are also increasingly elaborate, drawing enormous crowds into temporary structures and carefully choreographed spaces. Yet a pandal is not merely an artistic installation. It is a place where thousands of human beings must be able to enter, move, gather and leave safely—even when it rains, an exit becomes blocked, or panic spreads through a crowd.

Which brings me to questions that the investigation must answer: ‘Who approved the layout? Who inspected the exits? Who certified the safety arrangements? And who was responsible for ensuring that the conditions of approval were actually met?’

The organisers have responsibilities. So do the authorities entrusted with clearances, inspections, crowd management and emergency preparedness. If there were lapses, we must establish all those who were responsible for them, rather than assume that responsibility begins and ends with the person who happened to make an announcement or the individuals who have been arrested. An arrest is not a finding of guilt. Nor is the appointment of an inquiry proof that the system has corrected itself.

And compensation, however necessary, cannot compensate for the absence of a mother, a father, a child or a loved one. It can provide financial relief. It cannot answer the question that will haunt the families long after the headlines have faded: why was this allowed to happen?

I worry, too, about what comes next. A committee will submit its report. Officials will examine the findings. Standard operating procedures may be revised. New instructions may be circulated before the next Pujo.

But will anything fundamental change? Will every pandal be independently checked for safe exits, unobstructed passages, structural integrity and realistic crowd capacity? Will inspections take place on the ground rather than merely on paper? Will responsibility be clearly assigned, with consequences for those who ignore safety requirements? And will organisers and authorities be prepared to turn people away when capacity is reached, even at the cost of disappointing a crowd?

These are not questions of bureaucracy. They are questions of how much we value human life when it competes with convenience, prestige, spectacle and the pressure to accommodate just a few more visitors.

As I folded the newspaper, I thought of the families who had gone out to celebrate Saptami and returned home without someone they loved. We will rebuild pandals. We will welcome the crowds again. The drums will sound, the lights will come on, and Kolkata will once more surrender itself to the enchantment of Pujo.

But if the next year’s arrangements look reassuringly familiar, while the underlying failures remain untouched, then the inquiry will have served only to document a tragedy—not prevent another. A tragedy is not truly investigated when we discover only what went wrong. It is investigated when we make it harder for the same failures to happen again.

And perhaps the most sacred offering we can make to Ma Durga is not another spectacular pandal, but a city that refuses to treat preventable deaths as the price of celebration.

— Rudra Bose , The Last Writer of Kolkata

#rudrabose, #thelastwriterofkolkata, #whatif, #chorbagan tragedy

Are We Stealing the Future to Pay for the Present?


Reflections on Christopher Marquis’s The Profiteers, the meaning of progress, and the choices we must make.

I recently came across The Profiteers: How Business Privatizes Profits and Socializes Costs by Christopher Marquis. I found it interesting, disturbing and deeply thought-provoking. One sentence by environmentalist Paul Hawken, which captures the book’s central concern, stayed with me: “At present we are stealing the future, selling it in the present, and calling it gross domestic product.”

I have been thinking about what this really means for the future of humanity. We celebrate economic growth, rising corporate profits, booming markets and increasing consumption as evidence of progress. And much of it is progress. Economic growth has lifted millions out of poverty, created opportunities and improved the quality of human life.

But I cannot help asking a more uncomfortable question. What if, in our increasingly aggressive pursuit of the present, we are shortchanging the future?

When a company makes profits while leaving behind a polluted river, who really pays the price? When we exhaust natural resources faster than they can regenerate, are we creating wealth or merely liquidating an inheritance? When we sacrifice employee development, environmental responsibility or long-term investment to improve quarterly results, are we creating sustainable value or simply moving tomorrow’s costs off today’s balance sheet?

The costs do not disappear. They merely change hands, often ending up with people who had little say in creating them.

Christopher Marquis’s book examines this troubling imbalance between private gain and public cost. Consider Jack Welch, the legendary CEO of General Electric. Under his leadership, GE’s market value rose dramatically, and he became an icon of managerial excellence. Yet the controversy over GE’s refusal to clean up polychlorinated biphenyls, or PCBs, discharged into the Hudson River raised a profoundly uncomfortable question: Could extraordinary corporate performance coexist with a failure to accept responsibility for the damage left behind?

Welch’s later observation that shareholder value is a result, not a strategy, is particularly relevant here. It reminds us that business performance must rest on something more substantial than a rising share price. The larger issue, in my view, is not whether businesses should make profits. Of course they should. It is whether we have begun to confuse the means with the end.

Profit is necessary. But what kind of profit, created at whose expense, and with what consequences for the future?

This question becomes even more urgent as artificial intelligence transforms work, climate change intensifies, and economic power becomes increasingly concentrated. We could be entering an era of extraordinary human progress. Equally, we could be creating a world in which productivity rises while human security, opportunity and dignity fail to keep pace. The future will depend, in part, on which of these possibilities we choose to pursue.

So, what perspective shift do I believe is necessary?  I find myself returning to four ideas.

1. We must learn to measure progress differently.  I do not believe GDP is irrelevant. My sense is it is incomplete. An economy can grow while its rivers become more polluted, its citizens become more anxious, its education system produces graduates without employable capabilities, and its natural resources steadily diminish.

Should we not measure progress alongside the health of our environment, the quality of our education, the dignity of our work, the distribution of opportunity and the resilience of our communities? I would like us to ask not merely how much wealth we have created, but how much genuine human well-being that wealth has produced.

2. We must redefine what we expect from business. I have nothing against capitalism or the pursuit of profit. My concern is with a model that rewards the immediate gain while allowing the long-term damage to be borne by society. I would like corporate boards, investors and business leaders to ask four questions: Is the business profitable? Is it creating genuine value? Are its costs being honestly accounted for? And will the way it operates remain beneficial and viable ten or twenty years from now?

I believe executive incentives should reflect these longer-term considerations, and that environmental and social responsibilities must be supported by transparent reporting, independent scrutiny and meaningful accountability. A business should not be considered successful merely because it has made its shareholders richer. Its success should also be judged by the health of the ecosystem in which it operates.

3. We must invest in human capabilities, not merely extract human productivity. This concerns me particularly in an age of AI. I have been examining and writing about this aspect of late. We celebrate automation, efficiency and the promise of doing more with less. But I wonder whether we are paying sufficient attention to the people whose lives and livelihoods will be transformed in the process. If technology creates unprecedented wealth but concentrates the benefits among a small minority, can we honestly call that progress for humanity?

I would like us to place far greater emphasis on lifelong learning, reskilling, accessible education and the development of distinctly human capabilities: critical thinking, creativity, empathy, judgement and the ability to work meaningfully with others. The real promise of technology should be to expand human possibilities, not merely to reduce the cost of employing human beings.

4. We must move from exploiting the future to regenerating it.  My sense is that this is the most fundamental shift of all. For too long, we have treated nature as a warehouse of resources, people as factors of production and time as something to be compressed in the pursuit of returns.

I would like us to think differently. Can businesses restore the natural resources they consume? Can agriculture improve the health of the soil rather than exhaust it? Can cities become more liveable as they grow? Can economic activity create better opportunities for the next generation rather than leave it with depleted resources, fragile institutions and an enormous environmental bill?

This requires more than individual goodwill. It requires policy, investment, innovation and a willingness to accept that some of the most valuable returns may take years to materialise. But it also requires a change in how we think about our place in the world. We are not the owners of an unlimited inheritance. We are temporary custodians of a world that existed before us and, if we act wisely, will continue long after us.

So, where does this leave me?

I recognise that these are difficult questions. Governments must create jobs. Businesses must remain competitive. Families need rising incomes. Developing economies cannot be expected to abandon growth when millions still aspire to a better life. The answer, therefore, cannot be to stop growing. It must be to reconsider what we grow, how we grow, and who benefits from that growth. Nor can we place the entire responsibility on individual consumers. Systemic problems require systemic solutions. But citizens, investors, employees and business leaders can all influence the incentives that shape our collective future.

I keep returning to one simple distinction. There is a difference between borrowing from the future to build something worthwhile and consuming the foundations on which that future depends. The first creates possibilities. The second destroys them. Perhaps the most important question we should ask of our economic and corporate achievements is not simply, “What have we gained?” It is, “What have we left behind?”

Because if our prosperity today depends on making tomorrow poorer, we may eventually discover that what we called growth was, in part, a form of liquidation. And the tragedy would be that we knew the price all along but chose not to include it in the accounts.

The future is not ours to sell. It is ours to shape, protect and pass on.

What do you think? Are we measuring progress correctly, or have we become so focused on the returns of the present that we are losing sight of the possibilities of the future?

In musing………                                  Shakti Ghosal

References

[1] Christopher Marquis, The Profiteers: How Business Privatizes Profits and Socializes Costs (PublicAffairs, 2024). The book’s themes and the GE–Hudson River controversy are discussed in the Business Science Daily chapter-by-chapter summary.

[2] Jack Welch, comments on shareholder value, reported in the Financial Times in March 2009 and subsequently elaborated in an interview with BusinessWeek. See CBS News: Does Jack Welch Think Shareholder Value Is a Dumb Idea?.

After the Drums at Chorbagan


17 October 2026

Yesterday, Kolkata came to worship.

They carried their prayers, their hopes,

their children perhaps by the hand,

and the simple faith that they would return home.

**

The drums were beating. The lights were burning.

The Goddess was waiting.

And somewhere in that restless sea of humanity, seventeen lives slipped away,

not in battle,

not in the fury of nature,

but in the terrible chaos of a night that should have been a celebration.

**

Today, we will count the dead.

We will speak of compensation,

issue statements, promise inquiries,

and perhaps, in time,

learn to live with the news.

But how does a mother learn to live

with the silence of a child who will never again call her home?

How does a father return to a house

where one voice is missing, where a pair of shoes waits by the door,

where yesterday still lives and tomorrow has ceased to exist?

**

Do not tell me this was fate. Do not ask the Goddess to bear the burden of our failures.

What is the meaning of worship

if we cannot protect the living?

What is the sanctity of a festival

if human lives become expendable

in the pursuit of devotion and spectacle?

The drums will beat again. The lights will shine again. Kolkata will return to its celebrations.

But somewhere, seventeen homes will remain dark.

**

And perhaps the most painful prayer

we can offer the Goddess this year

is not for her blessings,

but for the wisdom to become worthy of them.

In musing…… Shakti Ghosal

Post Script:

oplus_10485792

When a Revolution Stops Asking Questions


History has a peculiar habit. It rarely announces its darkest chapters at the beginning.

Revolutions usually arrive carrying beautiful promises. Justice. Equality. Freedom. A ‘better world’ for those who have been denied one. And often, these promises are genuine. Societies do need to change. Injustices do need to be challenged. The young have every right to question the world they inherit. But history also leaves us with an uncomfortable question.

At what point does the struggle for freedom begin to take freedom away? Look at the history of the twentieth century.

After the Russian Revolution, intellectuals, writers and scientists who questioned the new order faced exile, imprisonment and persecution. Under Stalin, the machinery of the state turned against countless people, including educated professionals and ordinary citizens suspected of disloyalty.

In China, Mao’s Hundred Flowers campaign initially invited intellectuals to speak freely. When many accepted the invitation and criticised the Communist Party, the Anti-Rightist Campaign followed. Hundreds of thousands were labelled political enemies, and many suffered imprisonment, forced labour and professional ruin.

Then came the Cultural Revolution. Young people were mobilised in the name of ideological purity. Teachers were humiliated, intellectuals persecuted and families torn apart by political denunciations. The very people who had been encouraged to become instruments of a revolution could themselves become its victims.

In Cambodia, the Khmer Rouge pursued an even more brutal vision of social transformation. Education, professional status and the mere suspicion of intellectual life could invite persecution. The result was a human catastrophe.

These were different societies, different circumstances and different political histories. They should not be reduced to one simplistic explanation. But they leave behind a troubling lesson.

When an ideology begins to claim a monopoly over truth, the first casualty is often the freedom to disagree.

The danger does not belong exclusively to the Left or the Right. Nor does it belong only to revolutions. It can emerge wherever a movement becomes convinced that its cause is so righteous that ordinary restraints no longer apply.

The language may be different. The destination may be different. But the temptation is remarkably familiar. First, divide society into the virtuous and the corrupt. Then persuade people that those who disagree are not merely mistaken, but morally suspect. Next, make compromise appear cowardly, dissent appear disloyal and opponents appear unworthy of being heard.

Eventually, the cause becomes more important than the people in whose name it began. And somewhere along the way, the freedom to think independently becomes an inconvenience.

This is not an argument against protest. Far from it. Protest is an essential instrument of democracy. It gives voice to those who feel unheard, challenges the powerful and forces institutions to confront uncomfortable truths. Without protest, many of the rights we take for granted might never have been secured.

But a protest does not become right merely because it is passionate. Nor does a government become right merely because it possesses authority. Both must answer to reason, evidence, law and the rights of fellow citizens.

Which brings me to a question closer home. Whenever a contentious public issue arises, whether it concerns elections, citizenship, governance or social justice, we should resist the temptation to judge it solely through the political loyalties we already possess.

If citizens fear that their names may be wrongly removed from electoral rolls, their concerns deserve a fair hearing and transparent remedies. If an electoral process is challenged, the evidence must be examined and the institutions responsible must be willing to explain themselves. And if protests take place, their legitimacy must be judged by their purpose and conduct, not simply by whether we agree with those participating. The right to question a process and the duty to protect its integrity are not opposing ideas. They are two sides of the same democratic obligation.

We should be equally wary of those who demand unquestioning faith in institutions and those who insist that every institution is beyond redemption. Blind obedience and blind suspicion may appear to be opposites, but both can destroy the space in which reason operates.

SIR protests in Delhi

The same principle applies to our young. Young people should question their parents, teachers, governments and inherited beliefs. That is how societies learn and evolve. But they must also learn to question the movements that claim to speak for them. Anger can awaken a conscience; it cannot substitute for one. Passion can challenge injustice; it cannot make every action just.

And perhaps this is where our responsibility as a society begins. We must teach our children to think, not merely to take sides. To examine history, not merely inherit its grievances. To defend the right of those with whom they disagree to speak, because that is the real test of whether they believe in freedom. Above all, we must give them something more enduring than outrage: the capacity to build, the courage to question and the humility to accept that they may be wrong.

I do not believe every agitation leads to extremism. I do not believe every radical idea is dangerous, or every established order deserves to survive. Sometimes, it is the system that needs to change. Sometimes, the protest exposes a truth that those in power would rather not confront.

The challenge is to distinguish between the courage to challenge authority and the arrogance of believing that one’s own cause must never be challenged. That distinction matters more than ever.

History warns us about what happens when people stop asking questions. The more immediate question is whether we have the courage to keep asking them—even when the questions unsettle our own side. Because the moment we stop questioning those who claim to fight for us may be the moment we begin to lose the freedom they promised to defend.

In musing…..                                              Shakti Ghosal

The Coloniser Within


I have been thinking about a rather uncomfortable idea. We fought colonialism to win our freedom. But what if, somewhere along the way, we began surrendering that freedom all over again? What if…. this was happening as I write?

Frantz Fanon, in The Wretched of the Earth, explored how colonialism leaves behind something far more enduring than the physical presence of the coloniser. It seeps into the mind. It changes how people see themselves, what they aspire to, and what they come to accept as normal. The coloniser may leave. The colonisation does not.

I wonder whether we are witnessing a new version of this today. Except that this time, there is no foreign flag to pull down. No imperial army to drive away. We are doing it to ourselves. We have willingly entered a world where almost everything has a price, and increasingly, a value is assigned to everything. Our time. Our attention. Our relationships. Even our dreams.

I look at myself; I look at my friends and acquaintances. We measure success by the size of our bank balance, the value of our investments, the houses we own and the lifestyle we can display. We work longer, consume more and keep running, often without stopping to ask what exactly we are running towards. Somewhere in this race, life itself becomes an entry into a balance sheet.

Our health, our years, our quality of life — everything gets quietly converted into economic value. The hours we surrender become somebody else’s profit. Our anxieties feed markets. Our attention becomes a commodity. And the wealth created by millions of such small surrenders accumulates, disproportionately, in the hands of a few. The irony is that the balance sheet records the wealth we create, but not the life we spend creating it. It will record our assets when we are gone. It will not record the conversations we postponed, the sunsets we missed, the friendships we neglected or the years we cannot get back. It will not even note our passing.

I am not arguing against wealth, ambition or enterprise. They matter. Money can provide freedom, dignity and choices. But there is a difference between using money to live well and organising our entire lives around making more of it. Perhaps the real question is not how much wealth we accumulate, but how much of our lives we are willing to exchange for it.

Colonialism once took away our freedom without asking our permission. Today, we may be surrendering it voluntarily, one working day, one unfulfilled promise, one postponed pleasure at a time. And the most disturbing part? We have begun to call this freedom.

Perhaps the last act of liberation is not to overthrow another ruler, but to recognise the one we have installed within ourselves.

In musing…..                                                 Shakti Ghosal